what’s in a name?
So it’s time. The baby will be here in about a month and we need to buckle down and focus on a perfect name for the little stick-o-butta.
While everyone wants to know what she’ll be called and has been asking for months, we have decided to see what she looks like before we give her a name. We have a list – a top 5, if you will – and even a top 10, but who knows if any of them will be the right one once we see/meet her…we can only hope.
Of course, we were pretty much settled on a boy’s name and simply knew that it was a boy so we were all set – we did have a few alternates in case he didn’t look/feel like a “Charlie” but we were pretty set – and that was a nice feeling.
I didn’t think Charlie was a terribly popular or trendy name when I thought it was a name I could see giving a possible future son that a few years back, but as seems to hold true in the universe, once you start saying something, seeing something or believing something, the rest of the world jumps on that same bandwagon.
Now this may be fine for those who like and find comfort in trends and like/same-ness but that’s just not me – if it’s trendy or popular or ‘in’ you can pretty much count on me not wanting it. For example, no one was naming their kid Henry when I decided it was my favorite name about 10 years ago … until I said it aloud. I told someone that I loved that name and would someday name my kid that and then bam – it was everywhere. I mean, until then, I had only known one Henry in my entire life. Only one. Then one of my best friend’s dads had a baby and he and his wife named him Henry. So cute. Little Henry Hoffman. Okay, I thought – they live in California and don’t exactly travel in the same circles and I think it’s a family name so – I gave them a mulligan. Then it seemed that everywhere I turned, someone had a Henry. There were Hollywood Henrys and New Hampshire Henrys. I heard it called on the playground, in the grocery store … everywhere. And I was pissed. But did I have a right to be so? No. Of course not. It wasn’t even a family name for me. Did that give me even less of a right to stake a claim on this fabulous name? Probably. Especially since I had to admit to ‘laying claim’ to names that others used that were my family names. Like Parker and Hunter. But these too have become trendy. Too bad. I used to have a little fantasy that I would have twin boys named Parker and Hunter and when people asked where they got their unusual names, I would say, “family.” And that would be that. It would shut them up and I would smugly walk away. This was when I was in junior high and still wanted kids – when I got a little older, I was going to be a career woman and would have no time for the little beasts so the favorite baby names we relegated to possible dog names.
So Henry was out. I still love the name but dislike that it’s become so common and an ‘it’ name. And as I have said, I am a counter-’it’ person. I want classic and classy with a twist – not different for the sake of being different – unique but not made up. And no crazy spellings of classic names – that’s just asking for trouble.
So one needs to be flexible. Of course, I realize I’m not the only one who this happens to. Others seem to take it okay. Maybe I’m overreacting. Maybe it’s like art or thoughts or music – there are no original ideas as they say – someone has always thought of it or done it or made it before you. Get over it.
I mean I don’t want the kid to have a name that no one has ever heard of before or that will always have to be pronounced or spelled out for everyone – what a nightmare. My poor brother, Keir has had to deal with this his entire life and while I think he likes his name, this guy has had to endure some serious strife because of it.
Because kids love to rhyme words and names, he was hit with ‘Keir the queer’ his entire childhood – poor thing. Then there’s spelling – kier, keer, kir – like kir royal? And then there were those called him Peter .. Peter? Where’d they get that? I guess when you say Keir quickly or not enunciated enough, you hear Peter – yeah, okay – Peter – I think the kid just answered to whatever. But it’s a great name. And he is Keir. Maybe not the only one in the universe, but one of the few and the best one as far as I’m concerned.
Once we found out it was a girl, Charlie and Henry went right out the window (though there is a small posse of friends and some part of me that would love to call my girl Charlie/Charley) so that should make it easier, right? Not really.
When you have your first serious talk with your partner about a name, all this other stuff comes into play –what about a family name? From whose family? Should it be mine, because the kid is getting your last name? Does it matter that we are in a different country and she’ll be born here? Should we name her something having to do with the country or culture she’ll be born into? And they pronounce things slightly differently here – so do we take that into account? (i.e. Elle would be pronounced Ella here, etc…)
So you make your first list – broad strokes. You get to veto each other’s names that you would not consider. Me – I love Louisa (The Sound of Music, of course) the sound of it, the way it looks on paper… I can picture a little girl named Louisa running through a field with her hair in a bow, wearing a dress made out of curtains … well, you get the picture. It’s one of my favorites. Nope – he won’t even consider it – he vaguely knew someone who had a kid named Louisa and the kid was a pain in the ass, or weird or something… that’s all it takes, folks. One bad memory. Or sometimes not even that. Sometimes you just don’t like a name for no apparent reason. He feels that way about Charlotte, another name I like. No reason, just don’t like it. Okay. No Charlotte either- (but honey, we could name her Charlotte and call her Charlie! Nope. Not happening…) veto, veto, ve-to. (This whole compromise thing in marriage gets really old sometimes, doesn’t it? …)
And he likes lots of names that I must admit are really cute/sweet but that are really trendy. He balked at my reasoning at first then I showed him the social security site for top names in the US and they were all there. And though I really do like almost all of these, I just can’t do it. Maybe my kid won’t be like I was and will find comfort knowing that there are 12 other Ellas or Sophies or Emmas in their class but I just can’t do it. (There was nothing I hated more than not being the only Kristen in class and having to be Kristen V…. hated it!)
But what if said trendy name is really an old, recycled name (meaning used to be out and old but now is hip and cool because it is old. ..) and you have a family member with that name – is that okay? Will you always be saying, “Oh, I know that there are 12 Graces in her class, but she was named after her grandmother…” Another conundrum.
And what about the fact that the family names I like are not the family members I really want to pay tribute to? My grandmother, Mary Thelma (Worthylake) Hayward was v. special to me and she would be the one to whom I would pay tribute by naming a child after her. But while I like Mary, I’m not in love with the name and definitely don’t care for Thelma. I was set on giving the child the middle name of Worthylake whether it was a boy or girl and thought that would be lovely – and I love the name (I have used it as the name of my film production company and use it for a few email addresses too) I thought my husband was on board too, but he now seems to think that any name plus Worthylake Harbaugh will be too much/too long and I guess I’ve let him convince me of such.
I don’t have a middle name. My parents thought that Kristen Vermilyea was long enough. Good idea in theory I guess, but it kind of backfired as I just gave myself middle names according to my latest whim or more accurately, latest obsession. I was Kristen Marie when Donny and Marie Osmond were popular had their Friday night variety show (I also felt close to them because my Aunt Lynne went to BYU the same time they did and she once took a photo of them on campus – from far away, but still – and I somehow felt like we were connected – like I knew them – related even. I took the photo to school and told everyone that my aunt was friends with Donny and Marie and that maybe they’d come to NH for a visit. I also had my mom buy me purple socks because Donny wore purple socks and though I wanted to be Marie, I wanted to date – yes, I was young – 7- but a crush is a crush – Donny .) I was Kristen Olivia for a good long while when I wanted to be Olivia Newton-John. I mean, who didn’t? She was beautiful and had that fantastic accent and she could sing and act. Wow. I’m sure there were more fleeting middle names in between, but the ones that finally stuck were Brooke and Ashley. I think they likely showed up in junior high. In my memory, my parents were sick of me changing names constantly and one liked Brooke and the other Ashley and that became it. Looking back, I think the more likely explanation was that I liked these 2 names and instead of choosing just one, thought it would be fancier if I had 2 of them. It’s also likely that there was someone on tv or in a movie that had 2 middle names and I likely thought that was pretty cool.
This stuck for a while. Kristen Brooke Ashley Vermilyea. KBAV. A few people even started calling me ‘bad ass’ – Kristen Bad Ass Vermilyea – in high school I remember – which was exceeding funny as I was the least bad ass person anyone knew in high school. I found out at my 20th reunion that most people thought I was a narc. That’s how uncool I was… Recently I found a decorative piece of slate that my mom had painted for me when she was in her ‘crafty’ stage. It has a teddy bear in the center and my ‘name’ on all 4 sides. Kristen Brooke Ashley Vermilyea. How sweet that my mom wanted to make this for me but also, how mortifying. What do I say when my kid maybe someday sees this and asks who that is? How embarrassing… I think I may have hyphenated them at some point as well. Nice.
I guess I’m realizing that no matter what we name the baby, there will always be another girl/woman with the same name and that is okay. There will always be someone who says, “Oh, like Brangelina’s baby” or some other Hollywood star or musician or architect or astronaut. And it will be my choice to answer either, “Yes, just like that…”, or “No, not like that.” (Guess which I’ll be more likely to say? …) I realize that many people need context and a touchstone. Many people always seem to need to put you in your place and give you their opinion. Others are kind and keep their damn mouths shut and mind their own business. That’s what I call good manners.
A few of my best friends have offered up their names to the baby which is a fab gesture but sadly, one that won’t be accepted. At our baby shower this summer, one of said friends sat listening to the conversation that had begun about names. (The small group of close family and friends that was gathered was dying for a hint of what we were thinking of and though we had said we were not going to, I couldn’t not share a little … ) So after listening, she offered that Margot with a ‘t’ is silly because it’s silent and will bring nothing but grief. “Mar-got? Mar-got? Don’t name your kid that – that’s stupid.” And when the name Elinor was brought up, she said, “Elinor? That’s an old lady name! Why not just call her grandma – this is our new baby, grandma – doesn’t she look good for her age?” And it went on. Everyone at the table was in hysterics as she held court. She was honest and tough, but fair. Finally, after many more names and reasons not to give them to our baby, she offered this (in her precious Massachusetts accent which was slightly increased after a few glasses of wine) “As your best friend and the one who made you Godmother to her kids, I will say that I think Maureen Anne Ryan Harbaugh is a wicked good an awesome name for a baby. It’s served me well …” And so it has, my friend, so it has. Our baby would be lucky to have such a strong, sassy, fitting name as yours.
PS don’t you steal any of my names. I may just have another baby. Or get a dog. I’ll find out … you know I will …

I’m nearly 100% certain I did NOT say “wicked”! Although, I think you are being a bit hasty ruling out Maureen, if I do say so myself. It’s an “old” name that you scarcely hear any longer, yet, so beautiful and it does tie in to “family” also. Think about it!
XXXOOO
Just name her Tallulah for chissakes and get over it already!
Otherwise, are you sure you won’t consider Shloma?
The other piece of this, that is so interesting is how some people love the name they are given, like I do. And others hate it, like my mother in law, Lois “Arlene” and my Grandfather, Waldo “Leslie.” This means you have to make sure the middle name is just as lovely so if they hate their first name they can just keep that initial and go by their middle name.
Glad you’re back in cyber space.
I think Jennifer would be great….and i would set you up with a wonderful red school chair/desk with her name on it
Or how ’bout Anne…the wonderful mother that always made you tuna with yellow lettuce.
Love it! I’ve had numerous discussions with my wife about this very topic, and she thinks I’m borderline ridiculous to insist on taking the very stance that you’ve taken above. Trendy? No, thanks. Established? Yes. Fabricated names, or “creatively” spelled? WTF? I actually know of a kid named “Jaisin” — pronounced “Jason.” Rationale? They wanted to be unique, but not *too* unique. Wow. Besides the basic principle, I also like your taste in names, Brooke-Ashley. Interesting: one sister has a Charlotte (after our paternal grandmother), and my other sister has Charles (maternal grandfather). I also have a 10 y.o. godson named Henry; at the time no other kid had that name. Now: all over the place.
The Social Security website is a goldmine, and often a jaw-dropping example of the effect of celebrity on our culture — Khloe and Miley are big risers in the rankings. (Side note: look up the first year that Madison appears on the list — it coincides exactly with the year that the movie Splash was released, and Daryl Hannah’s mermaid character named herself that after the Madison Ave street sign. It was a punchline! And now it’s the 4th most popular name in the country.)
A pet peeve of mine is the arbitrary use of other families’ surnames as a kid’s first name, simply because they think it sounds cool — an acquaintance told me: “We want to call him ‘Jack,’ so we’re naming him Jackson!” Understood, but if they want to call him Jack, then why not simply do what has been established over centuries of Western culture…name him John. And as far as I know, the last name Jackson is nowhere in their families’ histories, they’re not fans of Jacksons Pollock or Browne, nor do either of them have strong loyalties to Andrew Jackson, Peter Jackson, Samuel L., Michael, Jesse, Reggie, Shoeless Joe, Mahalia, or Tito. We have other friends who gave their son some standard last names for his first and middle names: poor kid sounds like an accounting firm.
It’s refreshing to know that there are more among our generation who still have their heads on straight when it comes to names. I like where you’re going with this whole process, Mrs. H., and I look forward to hearing about the arrival of Zurich’s cutest arrival when she makes her debut. Stay healthy and hilarious, and raise a funny kid.
Great post! Thoughtful and fun and tweaky to those who bug. One other wrench for you: don’t fall into the trap of loving the first-middle name combo, or the first-middle-last name combo, without putting the first-last sound into the mix. You know, like “Holly Rochelle” fine and “Holly Rochelle Harbaugh” is also fine, but “Holly Harbaugh” sounds like you might need to put a stripper pole in her bassinet.
Funny how when I was reading your blog, and you mentioned “not having a middle name”, I immediately was thinking, “I thought she had 2… Brooke-Ashley…”. And it definitely was hyphenated then (8th grade):o) Good luck and keep the name to yourself until she is here… been there, had names swiped.